Pricing & Ordering
Five to eight flavors baked in store, per day. Stop by for an assortment or call to see what we have available!
Custom flavors are available! If there is a particular type of wine or liquor that we do not currently offer, please ask us about it! We love creating custom products for our clients.
Pick Up Orders
Please place your order at least 48 hours prior to your pick up date, by 4pm EST. Our cupcakes are baked fresh daily & made-to-order. Rush orders needed in less than 48 hours may be available with manager approval. A $15 rush fee will apply. Please call 845-395-9999 or email us at Lastcall4cupcakes@gmail.com to discuss availability.
You can either visit or call the shop to submit an order, however, orders must be placed in at least 48 hours in advance. Be sure to read our Ordering Parameters to understand how to order our cupcakes. Also, we always follow up email orders with a personal confirmation email so be sure the order is confirmed.
• When ordering, please note that we close Sunday at 4pm.
• Please note that cancellations must follow the same order time requirements (48 hours notice for cupcakes)
*Please note that while we have ordering deadlines to maintain freshness and quality, you can call the shop to see if we’re able to handle your order with less notice. We will always do our best to accommodate last-minute orders if we are able. Also, please note that we can book up earlier than these time frames during busy holiday seasons, wedding and graduation season, etc… Always be sure to get your orders in as soon as possible!*
Baily's Irish Cream/Vodka
CINNAMON TOAST CRUNCH
Fireball Cinnamon Whisky/RumChata
Vanilla Rum/Banana Rum/ White Rum
Marshmallow Flavored Vodka/Chocolate Liqueur
JAMESON IRISH WHISKEY
Jameson Irish Whiskey
Baileys Chocolate Cherry/Captain Morgan Spiced Rum
LEMON DROP MARTINI
Fresh lemon Juice/vodka
coconut rum/pineapple juice
CARROT CAKE SHOT
Baileys Irish Cream/Butterscotch Schnapps/Goldschlager
Rhum Barbancourt Haitian Rum
KNOBB CREEK MAPLE WHISKEY
Knob Creek Whiskey Maple Whiskey
Barefoot Bubbly Pink Moscato Champagne
Jack Daniel's Tennessee Whiskey
BAILEY'S IRISH CREAM
Baileys Irish Cream
Jamaican rum/fresh strawberries
Vodka/sour apple liqueur